|
What's your target
audience/station?
Does it do voicetracking?
How reliable is
it - why should we choose it?
What audio formats
do you support - MP3, WMA etc?
I can't get the demo
version to work?
Does it do
Internet streaming?
What's your
target audience/station?
Playout is targetted towards small scale radio stations - principally
hostpital radio & Restricted Service Licenses (RSLs) and now
in the UK, the new wave of community stations currently being licensed.
Primarily it's a 'live assist' package designed to be friendly and
easy to use even for people with limited or no prior presenting
experience. This includes at least one new community station and
a local school. In fact this is the major compliment and reason
for continuing to adopt Playout received from all the stations which
have used it to date. Please try out the demo
version to get a feel for the 'end system' and if you like it you
can apply for a free 1 month full version.
Does it do voicetracking?
Probably 'the' question I get most emails about and the
good news is after over a year in development, with the version
3 release yes it does. You can find more details on the About
page and if interested apply for a 1 month free trial license.
Voicetracking development is an ongoing activity and more features
are planned in future releases - see the future
developments page and the latest news on the development
page which is updated frequently.
How reliable
is it - why should we choose it?
Playout is a relatively new package - it started life in 2001 with
the first official release a year later but since then it's clocked
up a good few hours of operational use. On a stable platform
Playout has run without a problem for days and weeks of uninterrupted
operation in automation mode and has clocked up full RSL's of 28
days continuous 'hands on' and automation use also without a problem.
In fact there has been no recorded incident of application crash
or lockup since it's release.
By 'stable platform', Playout is as much dependent on your PC hardware
& software as any application - it's recommended platform is
a clean installation of Windows 2000 or XP with as
few other applications - such as virus checkers or webcams and the
like running on the same machine. These have been known to cause
audio 'hiccups' as has the older more unstable flavours of Windows
such as 98 & ME.
A key selling point for Playout is it's an intuative, easy to system
which even relative novice presenters can get to grips and feel
confortable with. In part, the package has been developed with the
invaluable input of one of the new community radio stations who
opted to test & eventually use the package for this very reason.
Many of their potential presenters are people with little or no
computer experience and Playout provides a friendly "non scary"
package to use.
Whilst OAS is a small outfit - it's been written with the benefit
& knowlegde gained of 10+
years working in the software industry encompassing extensive
working with various Windows platforms and in writing compact efficient
software for different platforms.
By opting for one of the inexpensive lease
options of Playout you also get ongoing technical support and
help plus the ability to influence the future enhancements of the
product. OAS has worked very closely with most of the stations which
have opted to use Playout & many of the features and capabilities
of the existing product have been driven by requests from these
stations & users. Above all else, the aim is for Playout to
continue to evolve as product that people want to use & enjoy
using.
What audio formats do you support - MP3, WMA
etc?
Primarily Playout is an MP3 player - principally for two reasons.
From a technical standpoint much of the underlying code is now optimised
for this format including a robust audio buffering engine to avoid
drop outs and extensive ID3
tagging support within the Playout
Manager tool. Secondly, despite what anyone says MP3 remains
the most prevalent and popular audio compression system around -
this despite various newer formats which sound 'better' or offer
more features, in reality most people can't tell the difference
and don't care. Not forgetting that every portable player on the
market will handle this format guaranteed - there's no competing
format that comes close. So this remains the recommended format
for Playout.
However Playout does now include support (in some cases experimental)
for other audio formats in case you have existing audio in other
formats or want to adopt another format for a specific reason.
Since OAS Playout v2.4 (April 2004), the following additional formats
are supported as standard:
OGG/Vorbis
- (.ogg). This is a fully 'open source' audio compression format
which has been around for a while now. The principal benefit to
this format is to developers in that there are no licensing or other
costs in using this format in your product. To the end user, the
benefits are negliable - it does produce slighltly smaller files
and I've seen quite a few listener tests where this format does
sound better than MP3. However it's not really taken off in any
big way possibly because none of the big companies have got behind
it. Also the encoder is significantly slower than most modern MP3
counterparts. It also has it's own tagging system (ie. not ID3)
which is limited (within Playout) to reading only.
PCM/WAV - (.wav). This is the raw, uncompressed audio you often
get when going to a more compressed format. Files are large (typically
40MB to a 4MB MP3 file) and even despite todays large hard disks
you'd be hard pressed to store too many of these. However it might
be convenient for storing the odd advert or temporary sound bite
in this format rather than worry about the hassle of converting
to MP3.
New releases of Playout now support the following additional formats:
Window
Media - (.wma), Microsoft's own audio compressor is the default
format to convert to on most Windows machines but because of it's
proprietary nature isn't universally available except on Windows
platforms and portable players licensed by MS for it's use. For
that reason it's not a format I'd recommend to use.
AAC/MP4a
- (.aac, .m4a) AAC (and AAC+ or aacPlus) is one of the latest 'state
of the art' compressors also (confusingly) called MP4. Primarily
this is the format adopted by Apple's iTunes/QuickTime
software however it is an impressive compression system, particularly
with AAC+ offering near CD quality at a fraction of MP3 bitrate
and hence file size.
I can't get the
demo version to work?
This question came up at an RSL meeting recently to which my stock
answer is always please, please drop us an email
and let us know what the problem is. As it turned out there was
a slight problem with the free version which meant it didn't always
display all the audio files in a given directory but no one had
bothered to let us know. Technical people are notoriously bad at
explaining stuff so if we don't know that there is a problem then
we can't rectify it.
Does it do
Internet Streaming
No, as a professional broadcast package most scenarios would involve
feeding the outputs into an external mixing desk (along with other
sources) and then streaming the combined audio to the Internet.
There are many (often free) 3rd party packages which will achieve
this final step - Winamp
provides free encoder software into it's Shoutcast
server software which we at OAS have used extensively. Microsoft
also provide similar solutions through Windows
Media Encoder.
Playout does however offer the ability to provide information on
track details to streaming servers via it's Track
Lister modules including both Shoutcast and Icecast
streaming servers.
|